Is killing for killing the answer we want?
THE EDITOR, Madam:
In recent months, the call for the return of hanging in Jamaica has been making the rounds loudly again. In The Sunday Gleaner dated August 21, 2022, there is a valuable read about the cons of resuming hanging. Statistically, it is not a deterrent to violent crimes in other countries. So, why do we believe that it would be different in Jamaica? The reality is that many of the persons doing these brutal killings, which usually trigger our call for the resumption of hanging, are not afraid to die. Death is not a fear, so how could the threat of death be a deterrent?
However, it does not mean that we are to sit back and do nothing as a country. People are genuinely fed up and need answers and changes to all the brutality that seems to be the norm. The recent vicious killing of an entire family triggered in all, or at least most of us, a gut reaction that has led some to call for the instant killing of the culprit. For those with this perspective, we should not be too quick to judge or dismiss them without offering something. It was a harrowing experience, and they need an answer.
However, is killing for killing the answer we want to have? Do we want the message that if you kill, you will be killed? How different would that be from what is going on among gangs? Therefore, as difficult as it might be, we have to offer compassion and mercy. Offering these two does not mean we forget or do nothing to persons who have committed heinous crimes. Instead, it means that we still see them as human beings who have been made in the image and likeness of God. It is difficult – in fact, could be impossible for some – but we do not lose our dignity, gained from being created in God’s image, because of something we have done. Indeed, it was this dignity that my brother Jesuits, Frs Alwyn Harry and Bryan Massie, saw in the two men put to the gallows in February 1988.
Let us pray for our country. Let us work to bring about peace. Let us work to preserve human dignity. Let us pray that we, too, do not fall into the trap of believing that a life for a life is the only and best way to solve our issues.
God bless us.
Fr Ricardo, S.J.
