Guilty verdict in Donna-Lee Donaldson case reaffirms faith in Jamaica’s courts

THE EDITOR, Madam:

The guilty verdict returned against Constable Noel Maitland in the murder of Donna-Lee Donaldson represents a defining moment for justice in Jamaica. This decision affirms that no one is above the law and that our courts remain capable of delivering justice, even in the most complex and emotionally charged cases.

This verdict affirms that circumstantial evidence, when meticulously presented and responsibly weighed, can meet the highest standard of proof. It affirms that jurors can rise above emotion, public pressure, and speculation to return a verdict guided by law and conscience. It also affirms that the courts remain a place where victims’ voices, especially those who can no longer speak for themselves, can still be heard.

The dignity and strength displayed by Donna-Lee’s mother, Sophia Lugg, throughout this ordeal have been profoundly moving. Her words following the verdict captured the painful truth that justice does not always bring closure. Still, her resolve reminds us that the pursuit of justice is not only about punishment, but about truth, accountability, and the moral duty of the state to stand with victims and their families.

Credit must also be given to the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions for prosecuting a demanding case with professionalism and restraint. In an era where confidence in institutions is often fragile, this outcome sends a clear message that the Jamaican justice system can function independently and fairly, even when the accused is part of the security forces sworn to uphold the law.

While the defence has signalled an appeal, as is their right, the verdict stands as a reminder that justice in Jamaica is grounded in due process. Justice has been done. It cannot restore a life, but it can reaffirm our collective belief that truth matters, accountability matters, and the rule of law still holds firm.

ROBERT DALLEY