Sun | Nov 22, 2026

Al Miller’s national award lacks good taste and sanity

Published:Tuesday | August 31, 2021 | 12:05 AM

THE EDITOR, Madam:

That Jamaica’s system of National Honours and Awards is in need of urgent revamping is impatient of debate. Indeed, former Prime Minister P.J. Patterson was himself seized of the need for this urgent necessity when he wisely appointed the 1996 Rex Nettleford-led National Symbols and Observance Committee the subtext of which impinged on how we honour excellence in the context of our rich afro-centric history.

Quarter of a century on, this issue has returned to sharp national focus, in particular the criteria for consideration in the awarding of national honours by no less an august and powerful entity of the state than the National Honours and Awards Subcommittee of the Cabinet on account of the debacle surrounding the dubious conferment of the country’s sixth highest honour, the Order of Distinction (OD), Commander Class, on the extraordinary controversial clergyman the Reverend Merrick ‘Al’ Miller. As you opined in your unflattering editorial of August 25: “Even after falling into trouble, and convicted, separately, for transporting a disquised fugitive and the irresponsible management of his firearm, Mr Miller has been recognised with a national honour… .”

It is troubling to the image of our democracy that Mr Miller’s conviction and role in one of the darkest periods in our fledgling history could have escaped the National Honours and Awards Sub-committee of Cabinet on which sits the serving attorney general, the minister of national security, and the minister of foreign affairs and foreign trade who herself is a trained attorney-at-law.

History will recall that following the 1996 Nettleford-led committee, several recommendations to avoid such a pitfall and to revamp the system of national honours and awards were advanced by the 2009 Human Resources and Social Development Committee of Parliament, chaired then by the incumbent minister of health, Dr Fenton Ferguson, with the insistence that “merit” and not “ascription” should guide the selection process.

In this context, the appointment of the Reverend Al Miller to OD, Commander Class, against the background of his questionable antecedents merely serves to resurrect murmurs of cynicism with a vengeance about the annual make-up of the national honours list in face of a political system already suffering from voter apathy and the withdrawal of enthusiasm. This has occurred given the deep suspicion that there is no willingness on the part of Government to effect meaningful change to the decision-making process of an entity of the State whose decisions annually ought rightfully to reflect the best in and among us.

As such, public disapproval of Miller’s induction into the Order of Distinction on the occasion of our 59th anniversary of Independence cannot be ignored since it threatens to derail the Government’s attempt to publicly acknowledge the achievements and solid contributions of groups of citizens in the 2021 Independence Honours List.

Al Miller’s national award runs the risk of spoiling what ought to be the good taste and sanity reflected in the Honours list.

EVERTON PRYCE

Justice of the Peace