Mon | Nov 16, 2026

Editorial | Ask the fiscal referee

Published:Thursday | August 28, 2025 | 12:07 AM
Opposition Spokesperson on Finance Julian Robinson speaking at the election debate on the economy on August 26.
Opposition Spokesperson on Finance Julian Robinson speaking at the election debate on the economy on August 26.
Finance Minister Fayval Williams speaking at the election debate on the economy on August 26.
Finance Minister Fayval Williams speaking at the election debate on the economy on August 26.
1
2

Whichever party wins next week’s general election, one of its first tasks in government should be the tabling of a revised fiscal policy paper, allowing the new Fiscal Commission an opportunity to assess its spending plans in the context of Jamaica’s fiscal accountability rules.

The critical core of that regime is lowering to, and maintaining, the government’s debt at no more than 60 per cent of gross domestic product (GDP), but in exceptional circumstances.

Normally, this policy paper is tabled ahead of the start of the fiscal year in April, for review. The aim is to demonstrate that the government’s fiscal programmes are consistent with its debt sustainability obligations. Since this year, this review is conducted by the fiscal commission. The job was previously done by the auditor general (AuG).

However, The Gleaner recommends early, if not immediate, engagement of the commission (which might require a broadened reading of law) against the backdrop of the pre-election spending promises by the Jamaica Labour Party (JLP), the incumbents, and the People’s National Party (PNP). Their proposals, on personal income tax especially, have ignited intense debate on the question of sustainability.

The PNP’s proposal is to raise the threshold at which Jamaicans pay income tax, from J$1.7 million to $3.5 million. This adjustment would start in April.

Additionally, the opposition party promises to remove tax from overtime pay, as well as from tips and gratuities earned by workers in the hospitality sector.

The PNP says that it plans to do this without raising new taxes, an undertaking which the finance minister, Fayval Williams, insists “can’t be done without imposing new taxes on the backs of the Jamaican people”. Otherwise, the policy would upend the fiscal stability and debt reduction (now at 62 per cent of GDP) that Jamaica has achieved over the past dozen years.

The JLP’s alternative plan, as outlined in its manifesto, is for “a disciplined, deliberate phased move towards a long-term base rate for personal income tax of 15 per cent”. Its larger policy is to shift to more indirect taxes.

REAL COSTS OF THE PROPOSALS

This newspaper has no doubt that either policy is achievable – once it is recognised that they both come with potentially difficult choices and trade-offs, if the new government is to abide by the commitments laid out in the fiscal stability rules.

This starts with knowing the real costs of the proposals.

Julian Robinson, the shadow finance minister, has priced his threshold hike at J$55 billion. That figure, on its face, seems credible, given the calculation by the former finance minister, Nigel Clarke, in the 2024/25 Budget Debate, that an increase in the personal income tax threshold to J$3 million would cost J$45 billion.

In that debate, Dr Clarke, now a deputy managing director at the International Monetary Fund (IMF), described the cost of lifting the tax-free income to J$3 million as “huge”, adding: “... It stands to reason that no administration in Jamaica’s history has implemented any single net tax reduction of that magnitude”.

While Mr Robinson hasn’t offered numbers on this front, some estimates are that around 100,000 PAYE employees fall off the tax roll with his adjustment.

On the other hand, Ms Williams, in a pre-election economic debate Tuesday night, cost her party’s proposed 40 per cent reduction in the income tax rate (from 25 per cent to 15 per cent) at between J$25 billion and J$30 billion, saying it was “doable”. Those numbers, on their face, seem questionable.

In the 2024/25 fiscal year, Jamaica collected approximately J$146.7 billion on PAYE taxes, or around 14 per cent of taxation income. Forgoing 40 per cent of that would amount to nearly J$59 billion. Mr Robinson said the cost would be closer to J$68 billion.

IMPORTANT QUESTIONS TO ANSWER

The Government hasn’t given a time frame for the implementation of its plan. Neither has it said what specific indirect taxation measures it would implement to offset the loss of PAYE income.

However, the Opposition argues that the Government’s proposal would mostly favour wealthier Jamaicans, while its own was geared to an increasing cadre of working poor and a middle class, which, it says, has been hollowed out by years of economic stagnation.

Robinson said that a PNP government would pay for its tax plan by growing the economy faster than the rate of one per cent projected currently for the medium term, which is projected to increase revenues by J$140 billion over three years. A PNP government would also shift priorities in discretionary areas of the Budget, as well as cut corruption and waste in government. Increased consumption generated by the giveback would also increase tax revenues, as well as help to spur growth, Robinson has said.

Whether these measures can, by themselves, offset the fiscal gaps that the policies would create, or whether additional initiatives would be required if the fiscal responsibility commitments are not derailed, are important questions to answer. So, too, are those about the areas of spending that might have to be reviewed.

That is why this newspaper hopes that, even in the few days before the election, they get into the nitty-gritty of their plans, as well as offer further details of the choices and trade-offs that are on their agenda.

It would help, too, if the new government initiates a review by the fiscal commission before becoming too tightly locked in on specific policies, and-or the phasing thereof.